Carey, Ohio

Your money works hard.
Your taxes shouldn't
work against you.

Expert tax preparation and financial guidance for individuals and small businesses in the Carey community. We turn complexity into clarity — so you keep more of what you earn.

Schedule a Consultation (419) 308-9428
Licensed & Insured
IRS Authorized EFIN
On-Time Filing Guarantee
Professional tax advisor reviewing documents at a modern office desk in Carey, Ohio

500+

Clients Served

Helping Ohio families and businesses maximize every deduction since day one.

What We Do

Comprehensive tax & financial services — done right the first time

Whether it's your personal return or your business books, we bring the same level of care and precision. No shortcuts. No surprises.

Personal Tax Filing

From W-2s to investments, we handle federal and state returns with meticulous attention — finding every deduction you qualify for so you keep more of your hard-earned money.

Business Tax Preparation

Schedule C, 1120, 1120-S, 1065 — we prepare returns for sole proprietors, LLCs, S-Corps, and partnerships. Plus, we identify credits and deductions specific to your industry.

Bookkeeping & Payroll

Stay organized year-round with monthly bookkeeping, payroll processing, and financial statement preparation — so tax season is stress-free, not chaotic.

IRS Resolution & Representation

Audited? Owed a penalty you think is unfair? We'll communicate with the IRS on your behalf, negotiate payment plans, and work toward the best possible outcome.

EIN & Entity Formation

Starting a business? We help you obtain your EIN, choose the right entity structure, and set up the financial foundation you need from the very first day.

Year-Round Financial Consulting

Tax planning shouldn't wait until April. We offer quarterly check-ins to adjust withholding, estimate payments, and keep you on track throughout the year.

Tax professional meeting with a client at Total Tax LLC in Carey, Ohio

100%

Audit-Free Filing Record

About Us

A local firm that treats your finances like our own

Total Tax LLC was founded on a simple belief: tax preparation should be personal, not procedural. We're not a call-center franchise. We're your neighbors in Carey — and we take that seriously.

Every return we prepare is reviewed for accuracy and optimized for your unique situation. We explain things in plain language, we answer your questions patiently, and we never rush you out the door. Your financial peace of mind is the only metric that matters.

15+

Years of combined experience

98%

Client retention rate

Why Choose Us

The Total Tax difference

There are plenty of places to file your taxes. Here's why Carey trusts us with theirs.

One-on-One Attention

You work directly with your preparer — not a rotation of seasonal staff. We know your file, and we remember you.

Accuracy Guaranteed

Every return undergoes a thorough second-pass review before filing. We catch errors before the IRS does.

Transparent Pricing

No hidden fees, no surprise charges. We give you a clear quote before we start — what you see is what you pay.

On Time, Every Time

We file early so you don't have to worry. Miss a deadline? It won't be on our watch.

FAQ

Common questions, honest answers

Ready to stop overpaying on taxes?

Schedule your free consultation today. We'll review your situation and show you exactly how much you could save — no obligation, no pressure.

Book Your Free Consultation Call (419) 308-9428
Contact Us

Let's get your finances in order

Whether you have a question or you're ready to schedule your appointment, reach out. We respond to every inquiry within one business day.

Office Address

2600 State Highway 568
Carey, OH 43316-1142

Office Hours

Monday – Friday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Saturday – Sunday: By appointment

Send us a message

Fill out the form below and we'll get back to you within one business day.

Is this your business?This is my business